4 of the Most Overrated Social Media Vanity Metrics
BY: Chris Makara
Feb 22, 2014
Home > Blog > 4 of the Most Overrated Social Media Vanity Metrics

Social media is no doubt filled with big egos and empty metrics. While I am a huge fan of social media metrics analytics, I find it somewhat frustrating with those who tout pointless social media metrics to measure.

With social media, it is important to know what social media metrics matter and which ones don’t. I am not saying that you should completely dismiss the metrics I discuss below, but you should take them lightly and understand how they impact the overall picture.

Let’s take a look at 4 of some of the most overrated social media metrics and what you should focus on instead.

1. Klout

I might as well start this list of with the most pointless social metrics of them all. Klout “measures” a users social influence and determines a score that falls within the range 1-100.

The higher the Klout Score, the more influence a person is said to have. While I understand the concept, unfortunately it is rather easy to influence/inflate Klout Scores. Therefore, I just can’t justify Klout as being a social media metric to give much credibility to. I will say, that I have enjoyed a few nice perks from Klout due to my Klout Score.

2. Number of Social Shares

Twitter Retweets, Facebook Likes/Shares, LinkedIn Shares, Pinterest Pins, etc. are not the social metrics you need to be focusing on. Sure, it means someone is sharing your content and increasing your brand visibility. But are those shares driving traffic to your website? Maybe a little.

I bet if you looked at the number of social shares for each channel and compared it to your Google Analytics data, chances are that the shares far outweigh the number of visits from that source. A large number of people share a link without actually reading it.

Therefore, concentrating on social shares is somewhat misleading if you are looking to social channels for traffic generation. You should be focusing on the number of visits referred to your site through a social channel instead.

3. Traffic From Social Media

While this definitely conflicts with the advice I recommend above, I think it is something that should also be looked at a little closer.

Not all traffic is created equal. In fact, of the website visitors you get from social media, do they visit more than one page of your website? Do they subscribe to your RSS or signup for your newsletter? Do they submit a contact form?

Basically, do they do anything that will ultimately increase your bottom line?

To really know, I would recommend tying Google Analytics goals to social media traffic to fully understand the value of the traffic and results of your efforts.

4. Number of Followers, Fans, Etc.

There is no denying that social media is a numbers game. The larger your follower base, the more people you can potentially reach. However, to really grow these numbers it takes time if you are doing it right. Even when you try to do things right, your profiles can fall victim to fake social media accounts.

Not only do you have to worry about fake social profiles, but what happens when one of the social sites you spent so much time on has become the next Myspace?

The social vanity metric you spent so much time on growing is now irrelevant. A better approach than measuring the total number of fans would be to attribute meaningful goals achieved as a result of your social audience. For example, track the number of newsletter signups or users who downloaded a guide that occurred from a social channel. These type of actions have more of an impact on your bottom line since they are showing signs/interest in what you offer and are ultimately moving further down your sales funnel.

Social Media Metrics Are Important

There is no doubt that social media metrics are important. You definitely need to measure the results of your initiatives. However, you need to be sure that you are measuring social media metrics that matter.

For example: You had 100 new Facebook Fans this month? 

So what? Did they engage with your posts? Click through and visit your site?

You had a tweet that was retweeted 1000 times?

How much traffic did it result in and did that traffic convert a goal on your website?

While the 4 social media metrics listed above might seem pointless at a high level, you can see by digging deeper into each one of them you can find meaningful data to track. Data that means something. Data that helps your business focus on social media lead generation. Ultimately, data that can show an impact on your bottom line.

What Social Media Metrics Do You Focus On?

When measuring the success (or failures) of your social media initiatives, what are the core metrics that you focus on? What metrics do you wish you had more insight on? What do you find difficult to measure?

Be sure to sound off in the comments below.

Chris Makara

Chris Makara

I have over 12 years of experience in Interactive Marketing & Digital Strategy, with a focus on SEO, Social Media & Demand Generation. I am an avid Football Fan, Golf Enthusiast & Ambidextrous Bowler. I can also be found on Google+, LinkedIn, and Twitter.
Chris Makara
(Visited 571 times, 1 visits today)

Leave a Reply

15 Comments on "4 of the Most Overrated Social Media Vanity Metrics"

Notify of

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
2 years 1 month ago

Completely with you on the Klout thing and I’ve been called a Klout basher. I simply don’t see what I gain from having it. I’m doing well without it. Since my dog, who has never tweeted for himself has a Klout score that’s higher than my son and husband who are actual humans, I just can’t get behind it. 😉 Great post!

Natalie K. Gould
Natalie K. Gould
2 years 14 days ago

Chris, couldn’t agree more. In fact I was just talking about this with a client this week. Too often social media metrics are divorced from “regular” metrics. I take a much more hard-nosed approach when it comes to evaluating social media success — really digging into Google Analytics and letting it inform my recommendations for clients. Google Analytics holds a wellspring of information regarding social media if we’re willing to spend a little time digging and setting up goals. The daily and hourly data I find particularly interesting. Thanks for this blog post.

2 years 11 days ago

Engagement? I have had several pages with high levels of engagement – but its been difficult to compartmentalize those comments – into positive, negative, action-worthy, irrelevant. FB should start a feature that lets you get deeper into understanding what your followers are saying – will help improvise the product/service/ be practive

Dave Heywood
Dave Heywood
11 months 21 days ago

Could not agree more – I recently conducted a workshop with my team about how we define our marketing reach and social likes/shares etc didn’t make the cut! Instead only counting those who go through to the web and then do something tangible.

At the end of the day when reporting at CEO/board level, they couldn’t care less how many likes we have…more what it’s doing for the business

9 months 9 days ago
I could walk down the streets of downtown Chicago naked and no one would notice because they are all interested in something on a 4 inch screen. Joggers jog with phones – moms ignore children – all tuned into social media. WTF is so important that it can;t wait until you get across the street? But it doesn’t scale – Coke has 8,000,000 Facebook fans we have 300,000 – one day I looked at one post Coke had 1000 likes & 80 shares we had a post at about 900 likes and 75 shares – how can that be (asking rhetorically) – it defies logical data precepts. So I climbed the mountain (via email) and asked the 3 wise men – Jon Loomer – Ian Cleary – Chris Voss – why do 1000 organic visitors from Google place 30 to 50 orders on our ecommerce site and 1000 organic visitors from Facebook place only 1 – 2 orders. I got the same answer in several forms “I dunno” confirming the lack of any holistic view of the web by any of the “experts” (Loomer didn’t know what a SERP was) No Chris – it’s not 4 – it’s EVERY social… Read more »
9 months 9 days ago

follow up – dovetailing CRO (which you offer) and social media – at the bottom of your site you offer 4 calls to action – one asks if I’d like a consultation – the other 3 send me to social media cesspools

would you rather have a conversation & try to close me on a digital serves package or have me circle you on G+?

K Mac
K Mac
5 months 2 days ago

Agreed on all this. The number of followers doesn’t matter if they’re not engaging. Sure, thousands of followers on Twitter looks great on paper, but it doesn’t matter if you’re not engaging your audience.
I say it all the time to clients and employers about social media: it’s not a strategy, it’s a tactic; one that requires an extra level of mutual engagement to be fruitful. It can’t be treated as a one-way street and it can’t all be macro communications. It has to be micro.
Successful social media is organic, genuine and relatable. The audience has to feel they’re gaining some measure of value by following you on Facebook or Twitter. Klout will never be a proper yardstick to measure that.
Just my two cents.

I’m Chris Makara and I share my 13+ years of
Real world digital marketing experience
without the theories or concepts.